I'm currently living in an isolated
area of the Atlantic Rainforest in Brazil with 7 other women for
company. We've had some good discussions around the campfire about
patriarchy and misogyny. But another thing we've been talking a lot
about is fantasy books. Watching Games of Thrones at night is
verging upon becoming a tradition. Sometimes there's overlap in our
conversations about fantasy and misogyny. There's someone here who
won't watch and doesn't enjoy reading George R.R. Martin's series
because, in her words, “It's just too rapey”. It's hard to argue
with that. Many have tried, saying that Martin includes so much rape
in his work because it's such a common part of life, both today and
in the parallel feudal history Martin in writing in. Again, true;
rape happens all to often, and often, the silence surrounding rape
culture can be deafening.
On the other hand, the ubiquity of rape
in our culture, and Martin's, does not lessen it's trauma. Much like
violence in all types of media, many of us are exposed over and over
to descriptions and images of rape. And, if we don't want to be hurt
every time that we are exposed to it, we must harden ourselves to
withstand those descriptions; make it seem further away. Limit our
compassion. Martin may write about rape in a way that is honest, but
he does not particularly write about it in a way which is
compassionate, to his characters or, especially, to his readers,
particularly survivors. For some, the constant depictions of rape can
make it seem further away, less meaningful, and for some, it can be a
painful trigger, over and over. Martin writes about a wide range of
violence in the Song of Ice and Fire series. Rape is singularly
unlike any of the other violence he describes in gory detail for two
reasons; it is commonly a hate crime against women, and this hits
harder to home for women than for other people, whereas most of the
violence in the story is not directly analogous to violence which
happens every day in real life to a particular group of people in
real life because of their identity. For instance, if it was common
to kill a particular group of people by pouring boiling gold over
their head, and Martin wrote about that happening to the same group
of people over and over again in his story, that experience could be
traumatic and alienating. But, luckily for us, that's not a thing.
This is not to condemn Martin. I read
all five of the books he's finished, and eagerly await those
(hopefully) still to come. He does seem to have some trouble writing
women without sexually objectifying them; we might have to read about
the way their breasts jiggle when they're doing something entirely
unrelated to breasts. But he does write strong female characters, who
often transcend gender norms of their time and ours.
The book I just finished, Wild Seed, by
Octavia Butler, deals heavily, entirely, with similar realities of
rape, slavery, freedom, and reproductive justice. But Butler is more
subtle than Martin; her method is not to describe a rape in gory
detail. She does describe, for instance, how a man is able to gain
power over and control a woman by threatening her children. That
relationship is the primary relationship in the book, and she also
describes how the woman, eventually, is able to become a partner in
that relationship, rather than a vassal or an animal to be bred. The
book takes place during American colonialism, when slavery and
genocide were rampant, and deals in a significant way with how
dehumanizing it is for people to have their partners chosen for them,
based on the worth of the children they would produce.
Like many of Butler's books, Wild Seed
deals with creating a family out of those that society has ostracized
or alienated; creating a loving, caring, intentional community. That
dynamic makes Butler's a feminist, and a hopeful novel. It deals with
power, but offers, also, possibility.